THE ROLE OF IPR IN THE ENTERTAINMENT INDUSTRY – Kartikay Sharma

THE ROLE OF IPR IN THE ENTERTAINMENT INDUSTRY – Kartikay Sharma

By: Kartikay Sharma 

(Amity Law School, Noida, Amity University UP)

ABSTRACT

Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) play a crucial role in protecting the creative works of individuals and entities within the film industry. IP also helps in brand reputation to help them differentiate with other brands in market place. IPR is granted under legal boundaries so it grants legal remedies and rights to the agreed. This sector thrives on innovation, storytelling, and artistic expression, making the safeguarding of intellectual property essential for sustaining the industry’s growth. The Indian media and entertainment industry has developed by leaps and bounds in terms of content generation, number of outlets and employment of advance technology. However, when we talk of content generation and its delivery how much are the contents original and how much can we be sure that the principles and regulations of the Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) have been adhered to in its making. IP rights is a major safeguard against any kind of infringement of the originality and the creativity of the makers, providing recognition to the talents of the creators and ensuring the dissemination of original and genuine work among the masses

INTRODUCTION – IPR (Intellectual Property Rights) 

Intellectual Property Rights or IPR are the rights given to the owners, creators, and authors of the respective intellectual property. Intellectual Property refers to, as the name suggests property born out of intellect of the creator, it includes literary, artistic, musical, designs, symbols and names use in businesses. IPR has various domains under it but the paramount ones are Copyright, Trademark, Patents, Industrial Designs, Geographical Indications and Trade Secret – (Referred from Kartikay Sharma)

IPR is bundle of rights given to the person for the creation of brain or mind in order to reward their mental labor or the creation of his mind. It also protects the creative idea of the person’s product and idea or a creative thought in mind is not protected under IPR. The idea should be converted into a product and then the same should be registered and verified under the IP law in order to grant them rights under IPR

Essential of IPR

• Protection of innovations: It refers for protecting the innovative idea from to take from another without right or without detection.

• Protecting Investment: Investors are often attracted to business with strong IEP portfolios as it indicates the value of the business in future.

• Revenue Generation: Generate revenue through licensing or selling the IP which also helps in brand reputation to help them to differentiate with other brands in marketplace.

Copyright

Copyright is the right which the author can provide to allow his work to be copied by another person. Copyright is intended to protect the original expression of an idea but not the idea itself. For example, A book, song lyrics, movie etc.

Trademark

Trademark is the symbol or logo used by the manufacturer to distinguish between other manufacturers. For example, are, Tata, KFC etc. A Trademark is generally required to be registered and provides a tenure of 10 years from the date of getting registered. 

Patents

Patents are the novel which have never existed before and the rights are granted by the government to encourage such invest inventors and contribute more to their field. Example- Drug, medicines etc. Patents are mandatorily required to be registered and protects the invention for a tenure of 20 years.

Industrial Design 

Industrial design aesthetically eye pleasing design in the physical attribute of the product. As it bridges the gap between what is and what’s possible. It is a trans-disciplinary profession that harnesses creativity to resolve problems and co-create solutions with the intent of making a product, system, service, experience or a business, better.

Geographical Indication

Geographical Indication or GI is any subject matter which belongs to a particular geographical location and is famous and known for in that particular Geographical location. For example, Darjeeling Tea is the GI of Darjeeling India. It is not required for a GI to be registered but is preferable to be admitted in the record kept by the governing body.

Trade Secret

A Trade Secret is a subject matter which is kept secret by the owner in order to not harm the trade and its operation in the Market, the subject matter may include formulas, medicine combinations which if leaked may harm the business. A Secret is termed as Trade secret only if it has been kept a secret and there is industrial applicability of that secret. A Trade secret is not required to be registered and is just required to be kept a secret.

IPR’s ROLE IN THE ENTERTAINMENT INDUSTRY.

IPR is used from script to screen which actually means that in every aspect of movie there is an involvement of IPR copyright and trademark are majorly used in IP rights in entertainment industry. IP law gives the film industry a wonderful platform to limit and prevent other sources from taking their decoration producing a movie or a video film is cumbersome process and involves long timeline due to involvement of different forms of art like script, screenplay, direction, music, literary work, choreography performances by the actor.

Entertainment Industry

Entertainment Industry is the ever growing and massively popular industry which generates massive profits, it includes movies, music, dramatic works, gaming etc. Entertainment industry usually generates content by obtaining copyrights for existing works and further developing the existing work, for example, a copyright is obtained for a book which is later adapted into a movie.

Once the movie is created, the next step is to distribute the movie to various distributors who further showcase the movies in cinemas and generates money from that. For this to happen distributors are granted special rights to distribute the film and not alter or own the media. In the Entertainment Industry, the only prominent IPR is Copyright as it is widely used in the industry in various capacities and degrees.

Emerging Trends in the Entertainment Industry

 Entertainment industry is an ever so evolving industry with new trends emerging in a short period of time. With digitization we are seeing new trends emerging such as streaming services, online gaming, online content, Ai etc which acts as a bane and a boon for the industry. On one hand the new trends are helping expand the entertainment industry at a rapid pace, for example online gaming has boosted in recent years reaching double and triple the plater counts than before. On the Other hand, the digitization of the entertainment medium has led to increase in piracy and copyright infringement.

Streaming services are paid services available to its users that allow them to access a big library of content at a minimal price for a fixed period of time. The users have to subscribe to the service and are allowed to access it according to the plan opted for.

Online Gaming is a platform which allows millions of players to play together with each other while sitting at the comfort of their home. Online gaming has boosted in India especially after the introduction of cheap telecom networks and cheap mobile phones.

Online content such as Instagram reels, TikTok, YouTube shorts are on the rise and are seeing massive growth. More and more people are joining the online content creation ecosystem and gaining millions of followers and generating income through it. Online content includes making video essays, makeup tutorial, gaming commentary etc.

Ai has been the revolutionizing innovation in the field of technology and has also shown its impact in the modern entertainment industry. From content creation, editing to post production Ai has left its fingerprints everywhere, on one hand it acts as a helping hand to its users, on the other hand it uses licenced works illegally to formulate its results leaving the original authors fuming.

These new trends have challenged the existing traditional distribution methods and licencing models in part revolutionising the Entertainment Industry and paving way for future trends to evolve and take their place.

Piracy

Piracy is the sinful act of copying, distributing, duplication of a protected work without any authorization from the original owner of the Work. Piracy is rampant in today’s time and leads to great loss of profits to the people involved with the original work. For example, recording a movie without authorization and further distributing it to other people is termed as piracy. Piracy leads to great economic loss not only to the creator but also to the country, as the profit is not generated and thus loss to the economy of the country. It further discourages the owners and creators of the work from creating new and original works as they are not able to rightfully benefit from their work. Some types of piracy are Unauthorized Online Streaming/Download, Torrenting, Train routing etc. Government is actively trying to combat piracy and their initiative can be seen as they recently made amendments to the Copyright Act of 1987 favouring TRIPS provisions.

CASE LAW

RG Anand v. Delux Films, (AIR 1978 SC 1613)

A landmark decision of the Supreme Court of India in the area of copyright law. The case deals with a copyright infringement suit against the movie New Delhi made by Mohan Sehgal in 1954. The plaintiff R.G. Anand, contended that it was modeled on the plot of a play Hum Hindustani written and produced by him. The judgment is remarkable for clarifying the concepts of idea-expression dichotomy and copyright infringement under the Indian copyright law.

Background of the case

The plaintiff wrote the play Ham Hindustani and it soon became very popular. In 1954, the defendant Mohan Sehgal sent a letter to the plaintiff that he wishes to make a movie based on the play. The plaintiff met the defendant and discussed the entire play. The defendant did not commit anything, but the plaintiff later came to know that the defendant released a movie titled New Delhi. After watching the movie, the plaintiff was of the opinion that it is based on the story of his play. So, he filed a suit against the defendant for permanent injunction and damages. Both the District Court and the High Court ruled against the plaintiff on a finding of the facts. The case finally reached the Supreme Court of India.

            Probable Solutions to Copyright Infringement in the Entertainment Industry

Blockchain Technology is the leading frontier to the persistent issue of Copyright Infringement in the Entertainment Industry and is a decentralized, peer to peer network based encrypted and immutable digital, federated ledger system. Blockchain Technology can be effectively integrated with IPR to safeguard intellectual property. Blockchain technology has various domains and finding the suitable one is of the paramount importance. With the help of blockchain we can safeguard IP by granting it an encrypted number and tagging it so that it cannot be copied further and if it is copied, it can be easily identified. Its ledger functionality can be utilised for safeguarding and management of licencing agreements while providing an online easy to access way to sign licencing agreements. Blockchain technology shows a way forward and Ip in turn can help pave the way by effective patents on the technology safeguarding the technology from being used without authorization.

Conclusion

IPR and the Entertainment industry has shown a strong symbiotic relationship which dates back to the late 18^th century. IPR uses its various domains to help protect the entertainment media some of the domains are copyright, Trademark, patent, GI and Trade Secret. The Entertainment Industry has seen a big change with the introduction of emerging trends such as online gaming, online content, AI, Streaming service and this altogether has led to some banes and boons in the system. The boons include piracy and its various elements which are responsible for plaguing the entertainment industry and resulting in a loss to the original authors and creators of the work further discouraging them from making original works. A probable solution to this problem is the Blockchain Technology which can help combat the evil of piracy and help the authors. But finding a suitable element from the technology is the next step in the process of protecting the work. In current scenario it is of paramount importance to focus on the newer changes being made in the industry and help minimize the losses caused by them.  

 References:

1. Intellectual Property, Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy: available at https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/intellectual-property/#Trad
2. The Heart of the Deal: Intellectual Property Aspects in the Law and Business of Entertainment, Journal of Intellectual Property rights: Available at https://nsuworks.nova.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1104&context=law_facarticles
3. The Heart of the Deal: Intellectual Property Aspects in the Law and Business of Entertainment, Journal of Intellectual Property rights: Available at https://nsuworks.nova.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1104&context=law_facarticles
4. The entertainment industry and India, inc., Research Gate: available at https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321534844_The_entertainment_industry_and_India_Inc
5. Intellectual Property Disputes In The Entertainment Industry (legalserviceindia.com)
6. The Role of IPR In the Entertainment Industry – IPTSE